A veteran I will call Terrence ran his electrical contracting company for seven years before he figured out his payroll was wrong. Not a little wrong — structurally wrong. He was classifying employees incorrectly, missing a state tax filing in a second state where he had a job site, and his "accountant" had not caught any of it. The correction notice from his state's labor department arrived on a Thursday. By Monday, he had paid a settlement that cost him $18,000 and nearly sank a project he was mid-bid on.
He did not have a payroll problem. He had a compliance problem that looked like a payroll problem until it was expensive.
Gusto is payroll software for small businesses that do not have a CFO, do not have an HR department, and cannot afford to be wrong on the backend while they are trying to grow the frontend. This review covers what it actually does, what it costs, where it falls short, and whether it is the right fit for your veteran-owned business with 1 to 10 employees.
*What Gusto Actually Is
Gusto is a cloud-based payroll and HR platform built for small businesses — specifically the range that most veteran entrepreneurs occupy after they have landed their first contracts and need to hire their first employees without getting buried in paperwork or compliance exposure.
The core functions are:
- Full-service payroll — runs federal, state, and local payroll tax filings, withholdings, and payments automatically
- Employee benefits administration — health insurance enrollment, 401(k) integration, workers' comp, and PTO tracking
- HR tools — new hire onboarding, employee documents, time-off requests, performance tracking
- Contractor payments — separate from payroll, handles 1099 contractor invoicing and payments
- Compliance alerts — flags classification issues, missing filings, and expiring employee documents before they become problems
It covers all 50 states. That matters for veteran-owned businesses where the crew might be in two or three states depending on where the contracts landed.
The pricing is where it gets practical for a business with tight cash flow.
*Pricing: The Honest Breakdown
Here is what you pay:
| Plan | Core payroll | Plus | Premium |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price per employee/month | $6 + $6/base | $12 + $6/base | $12 + $6/base |
| Best for | 1-10 employees, straightforward payroll | Growing teams with benefits needs | W-2 employees with EOR requirements |
The base fee covers the admin fee regardless of headcount. The per-employee fee scales with your team. For a veteran-owned business with 3 employees, the Plus plan runs roughly $42/month. The base fee covers payroll tax filings, direct deposit, new hire reporting, and the compliance engine. Plus adds health insurance marketplace access, 401(k) integration, and workers' comp administration.
For a business that has been running payroll manually or through a CPA who charges per payroll cycle: Gusto at $42/month is less expensive than one quarterly CPA payroll run in most markets. And it runs the payroll, not just the filings.
There is a free trial. No credit card required to start evaluating it.
*Payroll Run: What It Actually Looks Like
The payroll run itself is the part that matters most when you are deciding whether to trust a platform with your backend.
You enter hours — or connect your time-tracking tool. Gusto calculates federal withholdings, Social Security, Medicare, state and local taxes, and any deductions you have set up. You review the payroll summary. You approve it. Gusto deposits the wages on the scheduled date and files the associated tax returns automatically.
The tax filing is the part that makes the difference. Most small businesses do not realize how many separate filings their state requires — quarterly withholding returns, annual reconciliations, new hire reporting, local city taxes if applicable. Gusto handles those automatically. You stop being the person responsible for remembering every deadline.
What Sidney G. has said about this: running payroll manually is a full-time job you are doing for free. The moment you have two or more employees, the exposure from getting it wrong — missed filings, incorrect classifications, forgotten state deposits — costs more than the software subscription. The math is not complicated once you have seen the penalty notice.
For veteran business owners specifically: Gusto has integrations with military spouse employment considerations and handles multi-state payroll cleanly, which comes up more often than you expect once you are bidding federal contracts in multiple regions.
*Employee Benefits: Where the Plus Plan Pays for Itself
The Plus plan unlocks the benefits administration layer, and this is where Gusto earns its keep for a growing business.
Health insurance — Gusto gives you access to their small business health insurance marketplace. You can compare carrier options, set up employee enrollment, and handle the deducting of premiums from payroll automatically. For a business that has been handling health insurance renewals manually or through a broker you see once a year, having it inside the same platform as your payroll is a real operational gain. 401(k) — Gusto integrates with Guideline, a third-party 401(k) provider. You can set up employee enrollment, contribution percentages, and the employer match calculation. The 401(k) admin lives in the same dashboard as payroll. One login, one place to manage it. Workers' comp — Gusto can handle the setup and ongoing administration of workers' comp coverage, integrating the premium calculations directly into payroll. For contractor-heavy businesses, this is useful. PTO tracking — Employees request time off through Gusto. You approve it. It accrues automatically. The balance feeds into the payroll run. If you have been tracking PTO on a spreadsheet, you will not miss the spreadsheet.For a veteran-owned business with 5 employees: the Plus plan at roughly $62/month covers payroll, tax filings, benefits administration, and PTO tracking. That is one platform instead of a CPA, a benefits broker, a 401(k) custodian, and a spreadsheet you update every pay period.
*Compliance Engine: The Part Terrence Needed
Gusto monitors your payroll data for compliance flags. It catches:
- Employees misclassified as contractors
- State-specific filing requirements you have not set up
- New hire reporting deadlines
- Expiring I-9 documents
- Employee eligibility for benefits based on hours worked
The I-9 tracking is worth noting specifically. The form needs to be completed within three days of a new hire's start date. Most small businesses discover this requirement when they get audited. Gusto sends the alert and walks the employer through completing it inside the platform.
For a business owner who has been running the backend manually: the compliance engine is the feature that justifies the cost. The settlement Terrence paid — $18,000 — was not from running payroll wrong twice. It was from not knowing what he did not know. Gusto's compliance alerts do not make you an expert. But they close the gap between what you do not know and what the state assumes you should have known.
*What Gusto Does Not Do Well
I will be direct about the gaps.
Price increases at scale. The per-employee fee compounds. At 20 employees, the Plus plan runs $252/month before the base fee. That is not expensive for what you get, but it is not trivial for a business that is cash-flow sensitive. By 30 employees, you are looking at enterprise HRIS territory, and Gusto will feel underpowered for the price. Customer support on lower tiers is not instant. The base plan includes email and help center access. Live phone support requires the Plus plan and is not available on the base tier during standard business hours. If you are mid-payroll-run and something is wrong, that window matters. The mobile experience is functional, not great. The iOS and Android apps let you approve payroll and run reports, but the benefits administration and compliance sections are best handled on desktop. If you are managing everything from your phone, you will hit friction. Integration depth is inconsistent. Gusto connects to QuickBooks, Xero, FreshBooks, and most major time-tracking tools. But if you have a custom ERP setup or an older accounting system, the integration may require a workaround. The major accounting platforms are covered; the niche ones are not. *Who Gusto Is Built For
Based on hands-on use, here is who gets the most value:
- Veteran-owned and minority-owned businesses with 1 to 10 employees who need payroll, tax filings, and basic benefits administration in one platform
- Small businesses that have been running payroll manually or through a CPA per-cycle and want to own the process without the compliance exposure
- Business owners who have had a compliance scare — a notice, a correction, a penalty — and do not want to run that risk again
- Founders who want to connect payroll, benefits, and HR into a single dashboard without hiring a part-time HR manager
Here is who should probably look elsewhere:
- Businesses with 25+ employees who need sophisticated HRIS features, performance management, and advanced reporting
- Businesses operating primarily outside the United States — Gusto is US-only
- Businesses that need deep accounting integration with a platform Gusto does not support
The Verdict
Terrence, the electrical contractor — he switched to Gusto after the $18,000 settlement. His payroll now runs on a Wednesday afternoon. His state filings happen automatically. He got an alert last October that an employee's I-9 was expiring and completed the re-verification before the deadline. He set up his 401(k) integration in an afternoon.
His monthly Gusto cost is $54 for 4 employees on the Plus plan. His previous CPA was charging $175 per quarterly payroll run — $700 per year just to run the numbers, not including tax prep or filing corrections. He is ahead by more than $600 per year, and the compliance engine is running whether he is thinking about it or not.
For a veteran business owner with 1 to 10 employees who is running payroll in a spreadsheet, through a CPA per-cycle, or manually filing withholdings: the transition to Gusto is worth the setup afternoon. The compliance exposure you are carrying is larger than the subscription cost. The peace of mind is larger than both.
*Frequently Asked Questions
Is Gusto good for a business with just 1 or 2 employees?Yes. The base plan covers payroll, tax filings, and direct deposit for up to 2 employees at $18/month. At that scale, the compliance engine is still worth the cost — if one employee is misclassified or one quarterly filing is missed, the penalty is larger than the subscription.
Does Gusto handle multi-state payroll?Yes. Gusto supports all 50 states and handles the state-specific withholding tables, filings, and deadlines for each state where you have employees. For businesses with job sites in multiple states, this is handled inside the same platform.
Can Gusto handle contractor payments separate from payroll?Yes. Gusto has a contractor-only option that lets you pay 1099 contractors without running them through payroll. The two systems are separate, which matters for businesses that use both W-2 employees and 1099 contractors.
What happens to my data if I cancel?Gusto lets you export your payroll history, employee records, and tax documents at any time. You own your data and can download it in standard formats before cancelling. Good practice on any platform: export before you cancel, regardless of which platform you are on.
Is Gusto suitable for a veteran-owned business with no HR experience?Yes. The compliance alerts, new hire onboarding workflows, and benefits administration tools are designed for employers who do not have an HR background. The platform walks you through each step rather than assuming you already know what to do. The help center is thorough, and the Plus plan adds phone support for when you need to talk through a specific situation.
*About the Author
Randy Johnson covers veteran business growth for The Veterans Consultant, drawing on direct collaboration with Sidney G., who brings 43 years of experience across the Air Force, Civil Air Patrol, and veteran business consulting.Sidney G. has spent his career taking organizations to the next level — in the Air Force, in Fortune 500 companies, and now working with veteran business owners who are ready to stop being the bottleneck in their own company. He has led IT and security operations at Fortune 500 companies, earned the INC 500 award twice, and helped move HCA from the Fortune 500 toward the Fortune 100.
*_This article contains affiliate links. Learn more about our editorial standards. If you purchase Gusto through this affiliate link, we earn a commission at no extra cost to you._
Ready to try Gusto?Start with the free trial — no credit card required. If you upgrade to a paid plan using this link, you support independent veteran-owned publishing at no extra cost to you.
Try Gusto Free →Gusto handles payroll, taxes, and compliance automatically. Use this link and you support independent veteran-owned publishing at no extra cost to you.
Try Gusto →